Astro Shop  |  Glossary  |  Astrology App

  • aries

  • taurus

  • gemini

  • cancer

  • leo

  • virgo

  • libra

  • scorpio

  • sagittarius

  • capricorn

  • aquarius

  • pisces
    Stars and Signs: part 1 | part 2 | Hellenistic Astrology | An Amazing Encounter | Nexus of Probability

    Kevin Burk. Click to go to his site

    Kevin Burk has been helping people worldwide to improve their relationships since 1996, through his Relationship Coaching and Astrology consultation practice. A member of the International Association of Coaches, he holds a Level IV Certification in Astrological Counseling from the National Council for Geocosmic Research. His excellent web site, Astrological Horoscopes & Forecasts has hosted over 1.8 million visitors since its launch in 1996.
    Kevin's latest book, The Relationship Handbook: How to Understand and Improve Every Relationship in Your Life was released in October 2004. The Universal Law of Relationships states that our partners are our mirrors: they reflect our own issues back to us. We meet the ego and learn how to master it (or at least keep it in check most of the time!) so we can eliminate fear from our lives and embrace the love that surrounds us.
    Kevin has two books published by Llewellyn: Astrology: Understanding the Birth Chart (2001), and The Complete Node Book (2003). Astrology has received rave reviews, has been adopted as a textbook at Kepler University in Washington for the 2nd year Astrology Degree students.
    Kevin holds a B.A. in Theatre with a minor in Psychology from Wesleyan University, in Middletown, CT.

    Stars and Signs
    Stars and Signs (2)

    The Equinox
    May Day
    St John's Day
    The Solstice
    Celtic Fire Festivals

    About Astrology
    What is Astrology?
    Is Astrology Scientific?
    Astrology & Astronomy
    How Astrology works
    Hellenistic Astrology
    Free Will, Fate & Destiny
    I Am Destiny
    Astrology, Ethics, Destiny & God
    Nexus of Probability
    Astrology, Science & Destiny
    An Amazing Encounter with Destiny

    The Power of Gems
    Gemstones of the Zodiac
    The Hidden Magic of Gems

    The Human Aura
    Levels of Consciousness
    Karma: The Earth's Awareness
    Chakras & Relationships

    Astrology Home
    Astrology Orders
    Star Guide
    Relationship Analysis
    Soul Connection
    About Astrology
    More Info
    The Zodiac
    About Us


    Stars and Signs   [part two]
    the Constellations vs the Sidereal and the Tropical Zodiac

    In this, the second part of this article, Kevin Burk explains the difference between the Tropical and Sidereal Zodiacs, taking a sidelong glance at the Age of Aquarius and some myths and misconceptions. He argues that the Greeks never used the actual constellations to measure the positions of the planets, however, because the constellations did not divide the ecliptic into equal segments, which outlined the various qualities of different parts of the year.

    Although the Tropical Zodiac is used by the vast majority of Western Astrologers, it is not the only Zodiac system. The Sidereal Zodiac (Sidereal = Star) does take the precession of the equinoxes into account, and rather than beginning its cycle at the point of the Spring Equinox each year, it begins when the Sun aligns with a Fixed Star in the Constellation of Aries. The Sidereal Zodiac is also known as the Fixed Zodiac.

    While astrology was developing in the West, it was also developing in the East. Hindu astrology, called Vedic astrology or Jyotish astrology has always used the Sidereal Zodiac. Jyotish astrology has an entirely different set of techniques and interpretations for the signs and planets. The fundamentals may be the same as in Western Astrology, but the similarity ends there.

    In the 1930's, Cyril Fagan began to advocate using the Sidereal Zodiac in Western Astrology, rather than using the Tropical Zodiac. Although definitely in the minority, there are many astrologers who practice Western Sidereal Astrology, using basically the same interpretations for the signs and the planets, but an entirely different measurement system. Currently, the difference between the Tropical Zodiac and the Sidereal Zodiac is about 23. What this means is that the Spring Equinox, which occurs at 0 of Aries (Tropical) actually occurs at about 7 of the Sidereal Sign of Pisces. Because no one can agree as to the exact location of the start of the Constellation of Aries, and therefore to the point where the Sidereal Zodiac would begin, the Sidereal Zodiac is calculated backwards from the Vernal Point, using one of many different ayanamsas.

    Tropical Astrology and Western Sidereal Astrology have fundamentally different approaches to the symbolism and interpretation of the Signs. Tropical Astrology believes that the qualities associated with the signs are linked to the seasons, rather than to the fixed stars, and therefore the precession of the equinoxes and the growing difference between the Tropical Signs and the relative positions of their namesake constellations is of no consequence. Sidereal Astrologers (both Western and Eastern) believe that the qualities of the signs are not related to the seasons, but rather to the specific portions of the ecliptic as measured against the fixed stars.

    With respect to the question of the accuracy of ancient charts and interpretations, we only need to remember what Zodiac system was used at the time, and keep things in context. The Western Astrological tradition, which includes the Greeks, the Europeans, the English (in the Middle Ages), and the Americans in more recent years is based on the Tropical Zodiac. Therefore, all charts and interpretations from these times and places would be as accurate and valid today as they were then. Furthermore, the date, time and location information can be used to calculate a "modern" version of the ancient charts with no adjustments (except for the necessary conversions to translate the more ancient dates into the modern calendar).

    Any charts from the Eastern tradition, however, as well as any Western Sidereal charts (post 1930's) would require adjustments based on the precession of the equinoxes. The difference between the Tropical zodiac and the Sidereal Zodiac changes each year, and the degree of precession would have to be taken into account for the date of the chart. This would be rather nightmarish to try and calculate by hand; fortunately, most computer astrology programs that offer a Sidereal Zodiac option take this into account and can produce accurate Sidereal charts for any time or place.


    The precession of the equinoxes has to do with more than just the two different zodiac systems. As the equinoxes precess, they relate to the Great Ages of Man. These Ages mark different periods where significant evolutionary changes occurred. The Ages are defined by the Sidereal Sign that is the current location of the Vernal Point. Currently, the Spring Equinox (0 of Aries in the Tropical Zodiac) occurs at about 7 of the Sidereal Sign of Pisces, and we are currently very much in the Age of Pisces, where we will stay for another 150-300 years or so until the Spring Equinox precesses into the Sidereal Sign of Aquarius, which will mark the beginning of the Age of Aquarius. (Even agreeing on this definition of the "Ages" there is much dispute as to the actual year that the "Age of Aquarius" will begin. The reasons and reasoning for this aren't terribly important to this discussion. Suffice it to say that it's not terribly likely that any of us will still be here to witness it.)

    Each Great Age is associated with a major evolutionary and cultural advancement of the species.

    • In the Age of Gemini, language was developed.
    • In the Age of Taurus, agriculture was discovered, and for the first time, towns, villages, and cities were formed because humans no longer needed to hunt and gather for their food and so were not required to be so nomadic.
    • The Age of Aries ushered in wars and warfare, violence and conquest.
    • The Age of Pisces has been dominated largely by religion, Christianity in particular, with its peculiar mixture of persecution and spiritual salvation.

    The general thoughts about the Age of Aquarius are that it will mark a period of enlightenment and freedom. But once again, even the most generous estimates put this off for another 100 years at least.


    The fact that the Signs of the Zodiac share the same names as 12 of the constellations, and were, in fact, named after the constellations, has resulted in the popular misconception that the signs are the same thing as the constellations. This fallacy has given rise to all sorts of pseudo-scientific attacks on the validity of astrology, all of which come from individuals who do not understand astrology in the first place. Some have even come from a small faction of Western Sidereal astrologers who attempt to discredit Tropical astrology. I'll list some of the most popular examples below, and then, since they all can be explained or refuted by the same information, tackle them all at once.

    • "The 13th Sign of the Zodiac." This one pops up in the media from time to time. Sometimes it takes the angle that a new sign of the zodiac has been "discovered." Other times, it's used as an argument by sceptics attempting to discredit astrology. What it refers to is the Constellation of Ophiuchus, which also intersects the ecliptic, and which actually occupies more space along the ecliptic than the Constellation of Scorpio.

    • "The Sidereal Zodiac is the only 'real' zodiac because it uses the constellations and not imaginary divisions of the ecliptic."

    • "How can you say that 'Jupiter is in Libra' when I can look up in the sky and see it clearly in Virgo?"

    • "The Zodiac has all of the dates wrong because of the Precession of the Equinoxes." Part of this is addressed above when the difference between the Tropical and the Sidereal Zodiacs is covered. The rest will be addressed below.

    The data in the following table was published by Dr. Lee T. Shapiro, Director Morehead Planetarium, CB #3480 Morehead Building, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3480. The dates and days refer to the time that the Sun appears to spend in each of the constellations. I took the days (based on a 365 day year) and converted them to the corresponding arcs that each constellation occupies along the ecliptic. I also included the approximate dates that the Sun enters each of the Signs, both in the Tropical Zodiac and also in the Sidereal Zodiac.


    Sun Enters/Leaves

    # of Days

    # of Degrees

    Tropical Dates

    Sidereal Dates


    Apr 19 - May 13



    Mar 21 - Apr 20

    Apr 14 - May 14


    May 14 - Jun 19



    Apr 21 - May 21

    May 15 - Jun 14


    Jun 20 - Jul 20



    May 22 - Jun 21

    Jun 15 - Jul 15


    Jul 21 - Aug 9



    Jun 22 - Jul 22

    Jul 16 - Aug 16


    Aug 10 - Sep 15



    Jul 23 - Aug 22

    Aug 17 - Sep 16


    Sep 16 - Oct 30



    Aug 23 - Sep 23

    Sep 17 - Oct 16


    Oct 31 - Nov 22



    Sep 24 - Oct 23

    Oct 17 - Nov 15


    Nov 23 - Nov 29



    Oct 24 - Nov 22

    Nov 16 - Dec 15


    Nov 30 - Dec 17






    Dec 18 - Jan 18



    Nov 23 - Dec 21

    Dec 16 - Jan 13


    Jan 19 - Feb 15



    Dec 22 - Jan 20

    Jan 14 - Feb 12


    Feb 16 - Mar 11



    Jan 21 - Feb 19

    Feb 13 - Mar 12


    Mar 12 - Apr 18



    Feb 20 - Mar 20

    Mar 13 - Apr 13

    The table should illustrate clearly the difference between the signs and the constellations. The signs, you will remember, are units of measurement, each consisting of 30 degrees of arc. The constellations may take up an average of about 30 degrees of arc each, but they certainly aren't very useful as units of measurement.

    This is also the answer to the "13th Sign" myth. While there are most certainly 13 constellations that cross the ecliptic, the signs are not the same thing as the constellations. Why the Ancients chose to name the 8th Sign after Scorpio (which barely takes up 7 of arc) rather than Ophiuchus (which covers a more respectable 17.75) will probably remain a mystery.

    It should also be obvious from looking at this table that the Sidereal Zodiac does not rely on the constellations any more than the Tropical Zodiac does. While there is certainly a greater correlation between the Sidereal Signs and the constellations along the ecliptic, again, the constellations do not divide the ecliptic into equal segments and therefore they are not used as the basis for the Sidereal Zodiac. In fact, there even appears to be a discrepancy between when Dr. Shapiro notes that the Sun enters the Constellation of Aries and when the Sidereal Sign of Aries is thought to begin (for the year 1997).

    The discrepancy between where astrologers place a planet in the night sky, and where astronomers place that same planet is also related to the difference between the Constellations, the Tropical Zodiac and the Sidereal Zodiac. Based on the dates in the table, on October 24, the Sun would be found in the Constellation of Virgo, the Tropical Sign of Scorpio, and the Sidereal Sign of Libra.

    And finally, the argument that astrology can't work because the precession of the equinoxes make it invalid, or at least wildly inaccurate (which is essentially what the "scientist" was referring to who prompted Debbie's question), simply brings up the difference between the Tropical and the Sidereal Zodiacs. Along the ecliptic, again, the constellations do not divide the ecliptic into equal segments and therefore they are not used as the basis for the Sidereal Zodiac. In fact, there even appears to be a discrepancy between when Dr. Shapiro notes that the Sun Enters the Constellation of Aries and when the Sidereal Sign of Aries is thought to begin (for the year 1997).

    Once again, although the Tropical and the Sidereal Zodiacs are very different, they each represent an entirely valid system of astrology.

    This concludes the article by Kevin Burk.

    Go Backl Click to return to the start of Stars and Signs



    Go to Top
    Stars and Signs: part 1 | part 2 | Hellenistic Astrology | An Amazing Encounter | Nexus of Probability

    Articles | AstroMatch | Search | Books | Contact | Feed Subscribe to Feed | Forum | Postcards | Glossary | Links | Site Map

    Astrology on the Web

    Click here to go to Pisces Click here to go to Aquarius Click here to go to Capricorn Click here to go to Sagittarius Click here to go to Scorpio Click here to go to Libra Click here to go to Virgo Click here to go to Leo Click here to go to Cancer Click here to go to Gemini Click here to go to Taurus Click here to go to Aries

    privacy policy